Neither label fits. The second tension from the opening closes here: the loudness is not a verdict, it is a location problem. Jupiter brings real generosity and real opportunity. The Sun brings will and identity. A square forces a choice, and a choice you make on purpose beats one you drift into. The aspect stays loud until you attach a number to the dream.
So ask where the loudness lands in your life. In a natal chart it asks for proof behind the confidence. In synastry it asks two people to cost their encouragement out loud. As a transit it asks for a week between the brave idea and the non-refundable commitment. Same angle, three different jobs.
What to watch for, specifically: the yes that arrives before the arithmetic. The compliment you convert into a title. The favor that grows between the asking and the agreeing. The trip that upgrades itself in your imagination before your card is out. Each one is Jupiter enlarging a genuine desire and skipping the check. None of them is a catastrophe. All of them are expensive in a quiet way.
Name the flip side too. People with this aspect are rarely short on courage, and courage is scarce. The confidence that overshoots can carry a real project further than a cautious person would ever dare. You do not want to sand that down. You want to give it a ledger.
Here is the flat answer to the headline question. Not good, not bad — loud, and useful once you give it a container. Jupiter square Sun rewards whoever names the price, the date and the deliverable before saying yes. Do that often enough and the overreach turns into nerve, and nerve is the part worth keeping.
Three questions before you act. What does it cost, in money or hours? By what date will I know it is working? Who else is counting on the version of this I just promised? If all three have answers, move. If one stays blank, sleep on it and let the mood settle before the promise leaves your mouth.
One last check, because it changes every answer above. Orb size governs the pressure — a tight square presses, a loose one whispers. An accurate birth time, or both people's details in a synastry chart, decides whether you are reading a real 90° contact or two Sun signs that happen to sit three signs apart.
To see whether a live Jupiter-to-Sun contact is touching your chart on a chosen date, enter your birth details, the target date and the event location in the transit chart tool. It tests that one moment against your chart; a full month of personal timing is a separate read.