Four details decide whether a Sun–Lilith square reads as a whisper or a shout: the orb, which Lilith you use, the signs involved, and the houses. Get these right and the reading sharpens. Skip them and the interpretation blurs into generic tension talk.
Start with orb — the slack allowed around an exact angle. The worked example makes it plain: the square reference is 90°, the measured separation between the two points is 92°, and 92° minus 90° leaves a 2° orb. Orb is slack around exactness, the margin by which a real sky can miss perfection and still count. A 2° orb reads as a tight, loud aspect: the friction between identity and appetite is a daily, obvious feature. Widen it to 7° or 8° and the aspect thins into background restlessness rather than a defining theme. Some astrologers allow up to about 8° for a Sun square; others hold the Sun to a tighter standard. The number you use changes how much weight the aspect carries in the whole chart.
Then there is the Lilith question. Black Moon Lilith is not a body but a symbolic point tied to the lunar apogee, calculated two ways: mean Lilith, a smoothed average, and true Lilith, the actual oscillating position. The two can differ by a couple of degrees, and on a tight orb that gap decides whether the square exists at all — so pick one method and stay consistent.
Signs matter less than people expect, but they colour the flavour. Sun in Leo square Lilith in Scorpio hides appetite behind pride; Sun in Capricorn square Lilith in Aries hides it behind duty. Same 90° geometry, different costume. If you want a quick read on how the Sun's desire nature is styled by sign, the Venus sign calculator is a useful companion to the Sun's own sign.
Houses change where the tension lands, and reliable houses and angles require an accurate birth date, time and place. Transiting Lilith in your seventh house surfaces the appetite through partnership; in the tenth, through reputation and ambition. Without a birth time, treat house claims as approximation only.
The timing difference completes the picture. A natal or synastry square is permanent background — a lifelong theme, not an event. A Sun-to-Lilith transit passes in a handful of days and recurs roughly twice a year. Same angle, different clock.